Broken Hearts Read online

  Contents

  Prologue: September

  Part 1: The Following February

  Chapter 1: A Surprise in the Mail

  Chapter 2: Have a Heart

  Chapter 3: Resentmen

  Chapter 4: Surprise in the Snow

  Chapter 5: Anger

  Chapter 6: Everyone’s Mad

  Chapter 7: “I Hate Josie!”

  Chapter 8: Math Problems

  Chapter 9: First Blood

  Chapter 10: Someone is Happy

  Chapter 11: “Somebody Hates You”

  Chapter 12: Maybe Jenkman

  Chapter 13: Valentine’s Day

  Chapter 14: Erica is Worried

  Chapter 15: Terrible Trouble

  Chapter 16: A Stupid Thing

  Chapter 17: Dangerous Plans

  Chapter 18: “Hello? Anyone There?”

  Chapter 19: Another Victim

  Part 2: February, One Year Later

  Chapter 20: Melissa’s Turn

  Chapter 21: Missing

  Chapter 22: Dave is Guilty Again

  Chapter 23: An Intruder

  Chapter 24: Another Intruder

  Chapter 25: The Real Killer

  Chapter 26: Long Red Hair

  Chapter 27: “Not Luke”

  Chapter 28: Stabbed

  Chapter 29: Another Broken Heart

  Chapter 30: The Party

  Chapter 31: A Hooded Figure

  Chapter 32: On Thin Ice

  Chapter 33: Drowned

  Chapter 34: A Romantic Idea

  About the Author

  PROLOGUE

  SEPTEMBER

  THE FALL

  The day of the terrible accident was bright and clear.

  Erica McClain stared out the back window of the car as houses and yards whirred by. A few leaves had started to turn. The passing maples revealed patches of yellow and scarlet among the dusty green leaves. These splashes of color were the only clue that summer was fading.

  Melissa Davis turned the car onto Old Mill Road and pushed down hard on the gas. The blue Firebird responded with a roar. “Why are we doing this?” she asked.

  “Why not?” Josie McClain replied. She sat in the front beside Melissa, pushing the radio buttons.

  “It’s a beautiful day to go riding,” Rachel McClain added. Rachel, sitting in back beside Erica, leaned forward into the front. “Stop changing the stations,” she scolded Josie. “You’re driving me crazy.”

  “I can’t find anything good,” Josie complained.

  “Then put in a tape,” Rachel suggested.

  “I forgot the tapes,” Melissa told her, swerving to pass a slow-moving van.

  Josie stubbornly kept pushing the radio buttons.

  Erica chuckled to herself. Josie and Rachel, her older sisters, acted so dumb sometimes.

  Josie and Rachel were twins, although they didn’t look it. Both sixteen, they called themselves the Un-Twins because they were so different.

  Rachel had an oval-shaped face with creamy white skin and large olive green eyes. Her pretty face was framed by long copper-colored hair, which she swept straight back over her shoulders, letting it flow down to her waist.

  Despite her fiery hair, Rachel was the cool one, the calm one. She had a soft, whispery voice and a confident, deliberate manner. Rachel was beautiful, and she was used to getting what she wanted. She moved easily through life, like a graceful, sure-footed gazelle.

  Josie, with her dark brown hair and dark flashing eyes, was moodier, more temperamental, more unpredictable. Even though she and Rachel got along well, Josie worked hard at being different from her twin.

  She kept her hair cut short. She always wore long, jangling earrings. She had worked all summer on her tan, while Rachel remained as pale white as ivory.

  Rachel loved to shop and liked to dress in the trendiest styles. Josie seldom wore anything but jeans and T-shirts.

  The only way you can tell they’re sisters, Erica thought, is that they constantly fight without really getting angry at each other.

  Despite their differences, Josie and Rachel had a closeness that Erica envied. She also envied their freedom. Erica was fourteen, but her older sisters treated her as if she were six!

  She was genuinely surprised when Rachel had invited her to go horseback riding with them. Maybe, Erica told herself, now that I’m going to be in Shadyside High with them, they’ll start to think of me as a person and not a creepy kid.

  “Wait till you see the guy at the stable,” Josie was telling Melissa. “You know, the guy who gives you your horse. He’s a real babe.”

  “What’s his name?” Melissa asked, stopping for a red light. Melissa was pretty with a lively, animated face framed by long, jet black hair.

  “Chuck, I think,” Josie replied. “I was so busy staring into his blue eyes, I didn’t hear his name. When he smiles, he has dimples in both cheeks. You’ll have to check them out. I think he was about to ask me out, but a woman got her foot stuck in a stirrup, and he had to go rescue her.”

  Rachel laughed. “What a romantic story,” she said sarcastically. “Don’t you ever get tired of chasing after guys?”

  “What a question,” Josie muttered.

  “Erica, do you have a boyfriend?” Melissa asked, raising her eyes to look at Erica’s reflection in the rearview mirror.

  Erica could feel her face grow hot. She knew she was blushing. “No. Not really,” she said quietly, staring out the window. She chewed harder on her bubble gum, blew a small bubble, then sucked it back into her mouth.

  “So you’re going to be in ninth grade this year?” Melissa said.

  “Yeah. I’m finally in high school,” Erica replied.

  “Hope you don’t get Anderson,” Melissa said, eyes still raised to the rearview mirror. “He’s the pits.”

  Melissa was Rachel and Josie’s age and Josie’s best friend, but she’d always been nice to Erica. She always talked to Erica as if she were someone worth knowing, not someone’s pesky kid sister. She lived across the street from the McClains on Fear Street, which is how she and Josie got to be friends.

  Erica blew another pink bubble, a larger one this time. Too large. It popped and stuck to her chin.

  Rachel laughed. “Very mature,” she said scornfully, rolling her eyes.

  Erica smiled as she struggled to pull the bubble gum off, but she felt hurt. Is Rachel going to make fun of me the rest of my life? she wondered.

  The woods they’d been passing suddenly gave way to rolling green meadows behind log rail fences. A weatherbeaten wooden sign proclaimed Shadyside Riding Club.

  Melissa slowed the car and turned into the parking lot, the tires throwing up clouds of dust. Beyond the fence Erica could see several horses standing with their heads lowered, nibbling the grass.

  A gray clapboard barn stood at the far end of the parking lot. Behind it, Erica could see a dirt trail cut deep into the meadow and lead off to the woods in the far distance.

  She pushed Josie’s seat forward and climbed out the open door, shielding her eyes from the bright sunlight. “Wait up!” she called. Melissa and her two sisters were already hurrying across the parking lot toward the broad open door of the barn.

  “Hey, Chuck! Chuck!” Josie shouted, waving as a blond young man in jeans and a faded blue workshirt stepped into view leading two horses. He stopped to greet them.

  As Erica followed the others into the shadow of the barn, her excitement suddenly gave way to nervousness.

  “Oh!”

  Startled, she cried out, as one of the horses raised its head and whinnied loudly.

  I don’t want to do this, Erica thought.

  The horses suddenly seemed so tall.

  Erica wasn’t very athletic. Josie was the athlete in their fam
ily. She was a champion tennis player, swam like a fish, and loved to ice skate and play soccer and almost any other sport.

  Why did I agree to come along? Erica asked herself. She wasn’t much of a daredevil. She liked to keep both feet on the ground.

  When the carnival came to Shadyside every summer, Rachel and Josie eagerly clambered onto every ride. Erica dreaded them all—especially the one that spun faster and faster until the floor dropped away, leaving everyone pressed against the round wall.

  What was the fun in that? she always wondered. She just didn’t get the point of rides. She couldn’t figure out what was supposed to be fun about making yourself so uncomfortable and putting yourself in jeopardy. While her sisters would scream in delight as they whirred and tilted and spun, Erica would close her eyes, sink into herself, and pray for it to be over quickly.

  Now, peering behind Chuck at the tall creatures who were snorting and pawing the ground impatiently, Erica thought of the carnival rides and realized that horseback riding was probably going to be the same kind of frightening, unpleasant experience.

  She hung back as Melissa, Josie, and Rachel followed Chuck into the barn. She watched them talking and laughing. Chuck was a great-looking guy, she agreed. Josie sure knew how to pick them.

  Josie already had a boyfriend—Jerry Jenkman. Everyone called him Jenkman. Josie was talking about breaking up with him. Josie changed boyfriends nearly as often as she changed her socks, Erica thought, chuckling.

  She watched Josie put her hand on Chuck’s shoulder as she talked to him. “Boys love that,” Josie had once confided to Erica. “It makes them think you’re really hot for them.”

  Chuck had led four horses out of their stalls and tethered them. Now he was pulling blankets and saddles off a pile against the barn wall.

  As she watched from the doorway, a cold feeling of dread tightened Erica’s stomach.

  It smells so gross in here, she thought.

  Chuck asked the girls if they’d mind saddling their own horses. He flashed them all a dimpled smile as he hurried out of the barn to help some new arrivals.

  “Erica, do you want the black one?” Josie called. “Come over here. What are you doing?”

  Erica reluctantly made her way across the straw-littered floor to the others. “I—I don’t think I’m going to ride,” she said, training her eyes on the black horse Melissa was holding by the reins. The horse’s eyes widened and its nostrils flared as Erica moved closer.

  It looks like a monster, Erica thought fearfully, a dark monster.

  “Huh?” Rachel’s mouth dropped open in surprise and she brushed a fly off her pale forehead.

  “You’re not going to ride?” Josie asked impatiently. “Are you sick or something?”

  “A stomach ache,” Erica muttered, making a face.

  “Erica, every time we do something a little fun, you say you have a stomach ache,” Josie complained.

  Erica chewed hard on her bubble gum. She could feel her face growing hot. She knew she was blushing. Josie was right, she realized. I really need to think of another excuse.

  “That’s not fair!” she protested. “I can’t help it if my stomach hurts.”

  “We already paid for your horse,” Melissa said quietly. Her blue eyes burned into Erica’s, as if trying to determine if Erica was telling the truth.

  “I’ll go get the money back. Then I’ll wait for you here,” Erica said.

  Josie started to protest, but Rachel interrupted her. “That’s fine,” she said, coming to Erica’s defense. “You don’t have to ride if you don’t want to.”

  “My stomach really does hurt,” Erica lied, holding her stomach for better effect.

  “Do you want me to stay with you? Or drive you home?” Rachel offered with genuine concern.

  “Rachel, she’s just a chicken,” Josie muttered, staring accusingly at Erica.

  “No, I’m not,” Erica insisted. “I want to ride. I really do.”

  “Erica, none of us is any good at it, if that’s what you’re worried about,” Melissa said, glancing at Josie. “Josie and I have only been riding once before. Don’t tell Chuck. We lied to him the last time and said we were experts.”

  “We’ll go slow,” Josie offered.

  “Maybe I’ll feel better in a little bit,” Erica told them. “Then I’ll catch up to you.”

  She hated being so frightened, but there wasn’t anything she could do about it. Also, the smell from the stable really was making her feel sick.

  Josie started to argue some more, but Melissa stopped her. “We’re using up our whole hour,” Melissa complained, glancing at her watch.

  “You’re right,” Josie quickly agreed, turning away from Erica. “Come on. Saddle up. Hurry.” She made her way over to claim the black horse. “See you later, Erica,” she called.

  A jumble of feelings swept over Erica. She felt relieved. And disappointed in herself. And angry that she hadn’t tried to overcome her fear. And grateful that her sisters hadn’t insisted she come along. She slumped down on a wooden bench against the wall, crossed her arms over her chest, and tried not to inhale the pungent aromas.

  Rachel’s horse, a big chestnut-colored gelding with one brown eye and one blue eye, pawed the dirt floor restlessly as Rachel attempted to fasten the saddle’s girth. “Could you help me?” Rachel asked Josie, taking a step back. “I’m not sure I’m doing this right.”

  Josie finished with her horse, then, slapping a fly off her arm, shoved Rachel out of the way to fasten her sister’s girth. “I think you pulled it too tight,” she said, showing Rachel the girth. “Steady, fella. Steady. What’s your problem?” She put a hand on the horse’s neck. “You’re as nervous as Erica.”

  “I heard that!” Erica called from the bench.

  “Are you feeling better?” Rachel called to her.

  “A little,” Erica said. “I’ll catch up in a little while. Maybe.”

  “Yeah. Sure,” Josie muttered sarcastically. “Did I do Rachel’s saddle right, Melissa?”

  Melissa had already led her horse outside and mounted it. It was a dappled white and brown Appaloosa with a weary expression. “Looks okay from here,” she called in. “Hurry. We’re going to spend all our time in the stable yard.”

  Rachel led her horse out, put her left foot in the stirrup, grabbed the saddlehorn, and started to pull herself up. Her horse shivered, then flicked its tail with a violent snap. “Whoa!” she cried out in surprise, slipping back to the ground. “Why’d he do that?”

  Josie and Melissa laughed.

  “Don’t take it personally,” Josie teased.

  “He was probably bitten by a horsefly or something,” Melissa said.

  Rachel grabbed the saddlehorn, pushed her foot into the stirrup, and tried again. This time she managed to pull herself all the way up.

  “Ta-daa!” she sang out, smiling. With a toss of her head, she sent her long red hair sailing behind her shoulders.

  “Where’s your helmet?” Melissa asked Rachel.

  “Shh! Don’t say anything. I hate to wear them. I want to get out of here without anyone noticing.”

  “Let’s go then!” Josie urged, lowering her heels, the reins secure in her hands. Her horse led the way as they trotted along the dirt path toward the trail behind the barn.

  “I feel bad about Erica,” Melissa said, glancing back toward the stable.

  “She’s still such a kid,” Josie said, shaking her head disapprovingly.

  “Give her a break.” Rachel bounced awkwardly as her horse pulled ahead of the others. “She just gets frightened sometimes. Whoa. Whoa,” she commanded the horse. “What’s your hurry?”

  “You’re right. I shouldn’t be so hard on her,” Josie said, catching up to Rachel.

  “Ninth grade is tough,” Melissa said, appearing even tinier and skinnier than usual as she bobbed on top of the horse. “Changing schools and everything.”

  “Yeah. She’s so excited about being in the same school with us,�
� Josie replied. “Like she doesn’t see us enough at home.”

  “Whoa!” Rachel said to her horse. “What’s this horse’s name, anyway, Speed Demon?”

  “No. Granny Lady!” Josie joked.

  All three of them laughed.

  Rachel tossed her long hair as her horse trotted ahead of the others.

  The narrow dirt trail led through a meadow of tall grass, which swayed gently in the soft breeze. Crickets sent out a steady electric whistle. A small brown animal, a chipmunk maybe, scampered across the path in front of Rachel’s horse.

  The meadow ended in a line of tall, blue-green evergreens. The path narrowed as it curved through the woods. The tall trees blocked most of the sunlight. The cricket sounds suddenly stopped. The air smelled piney and sweet.

  Rachel’s horse slowed to a walk. It set its own pace, as if it were entirely in charge. Josie and Melissa slowed their horses to keep pace with hers. “It’s so pretty here,” Rachel said, her eyes exploring the shadows from the gently shimmering trees.

  “I can’t believe summer is over,” Melissa said, pulling back on her reins.

  “It’s definitely over,” Josie groaned. “I was at the mall yesterday, buying new jeans for school. Half of Shadyside High was there.”

  “What are you doing tonight?” Melissa asked Josie, changing the subject. “Going out with Jenkman?”

  Josie made a face. “Yeah. Probably.” A devilish grin spread across her face. “Unless Chuck asks me.”

  “Give me a break!” Melissa exclaimed. “Don’t tell me you’re breaking up with Jenkman already.”

  “Why shouldn’t she?” Rachel said. “She’s been going with him for nearly a month.”

  “Ha-ha,” Josie replied sarcastically. “You’re just jealous, Rachel, because I know a lot of guys. You and Luke are like some old married couple.”

  “We are not,” Rachel protested. Her horse began to pick up speed again, trotting almost silently over the pine needle-covered ground.

  “How long have you been going with Luke? Since you were in diapers?” Melissa teased Rachel.

  “Since we were freshmen,” Rachel told her, sticking her tongue out.

  “How boring,” Josie groaned. She tightened her grip with her legs as her horse picked up speed to catch up with Rachel’s.